Retraction, Withdrawal, and Correction (R-W-C) Policy

MONETA • PUBLICATION INTEGRITY & SCHOLARLY RECORD
Retraction, Withdrawal, and Correction (R-W-C) Policy

Transparent and accountable procedures for correcting, updating, and preserving the scholarly record.

Policy Statement

Moneta: Journal of Economics and Finance, published by PT Penerbit Ilmiah Indonesia under the publishing brand Indonesian Scientific Publication (IDSCIPUB), is committed to maintaining the integrity, accuracy, transparency, and reliability of the scholarly record.

The journal provides mechanisms for addressing significant errors, unreliable findings, ethical violations, and other concerns affecting submitted or published research.

This policy is informed by the COPE Retraction Guidelines (2025) and NISO RP-45-2024: Communication of Retractions, Removals, and Expressions of Concern (CREC). Editorial responses are determined according to the nature, seriousness, and available evidence of each case.

Fundamental Principle The primary purpose of retraction, correction, and related editorial notices is to protect the reliability of the scholarly record, not to punish authors. Decisions must be evidence-based, proportionate, transparent, and procedurally fair.
Retraction Unreliable Publication
Withdrawal Before Publication
Expression of Concern Unresolved Concerns
Correction Correctable Errors
R-W-C Editorial Workflow
Moneta Retraction, Withdrawal, and Correction workflow diagram

Figure 1. Overview of the Retraction, Withdrawal, and Correction procedures.

1. Retraction Policy

Retraction is a formal editorial action indicating that a published article is unreliable, invalid, or affected by serious ethical or publication-integrity concerns.

Retraction may be considered when:

  • Unreliable Findings: Major errors in data, statistical calculations, econometric models, research design, or analytical interpretation materially undermine the findings.
  • Fabrication or Falsification: Financial records, survey responses, market observations, statistical results, or other research data have been fabricated or deliberately manipulated.
  • Plagiarism: Substantial text, ideas, data, models, or analyses have been used without appropriate attribution.
  • Duplicate or Redundant Publication: The work substantially reproduces previously published research without appropriate disclosure, permission, or justification.
  • Unethical Research: Research was conducted in serious violation of applicable ethical, consent, confidentiality, or legal requirements.
  • Manipulated Peer Review: The publication decision was materially compromised by fabricated reviewer identities, fraudulent reports, or organized manipulation.
  • Unauthorized Materials: Serious copyright infringement, unauthorized data use, or other legal problems affect the published work.
  • Undisclosed Competing Interests: A significant undisclosed interest materially undermined the interpretation of findings or independent editorial evaluation.
Retraction Principle Retraction may result from an honest major error as well as research misconduct. It does not automatically establish intentional wrongdoing.
2. Retraction Assessment and Procedure

The Editorial Team assesses retraction concerns through a documented process appropriate to the seriousness and complexity of the case.

  1. Report Received: A concern is submitted by an author, reviewer, editor, reader, institution, or other relevant party.
  2. Preliminary Assessment: The Editor-in-Chief or authorized editor examines the available evidence and determines whether further inquiry is warranted.
  3. Author Communication: The affected authors are normally informed of the concern and given an appropriate opportunity to respond.
  4. Further Investigation: The journal may request supporting data, obtain expert opinions, or communicate with the authors' institutions.
  5. Editorial Decision: The Editor-in-Chief or another independent authorized decision-maker determines the appropriate action.
  6. Public Notice: Where retraction is required, a formal notice is published and permanently linked to the original article.
  7. Metadata Update: Relevant journal records, DOI metadata, and indexing information are updated where supported by the applicable services.
Editorial Authority: A retraction may proceed despite disagreement from one or more authors when sufficient evidence establishes that the scholarly record requires correction. The publisher supports the implementation and communication of the editorial decision.
3. Manuscript Withdrawal Policy

Withdrawal refers primarily to the formal termination of an unpublished manuscript's editorial or production process.

Authors may request withdrawal of a manuscript before formal publication by providing a written explanation to the Editorial Office.

Legitimate reasons may include:

  • Accidental or duplicate submission.
  • Identification of significant methodological or analytical errors.
  • Unresolved authorship or intellectual-property concerns.
  • Discovery of serious ethical or research-integrity problems.
  • Other reasonable circumstances requiring discontinuation of the submission.
Withdrawal Request Requirements
  • Manuscript title and identification number.
  • Name and contact details of the corresponding author.
  • Reason for the withdrawal request.
  • Confirmation of relevant co-author agreement.
  • Supporting evidence where appropriate.

The handling editor reviews the request, and the Editor-in-Chief or authorized editor determines whether it should be approved.

Withdrawn unpublished manuscripts remain documented within appropriate editorial records. A public withdrawal notice is generally necessary only when a citable public record, published metadata, or online version requires clarification.

If a manuscript is withdrawn during the revision process, a penalty fee of IDR 700,000 (or USD 45) will be charged to cover the administrative and processing costs incurred by the journal.

4. Withdrawal or Removal After Publication

Once an article has been formally published as the Version of Record (VoR), withdrawal is strongly discouraged.

Concerns about an already published article should normally be addressed through a correction, Expression of Concern, or retraction rather than removal.

Exceptional removal may be considered where:

  • A legal requirement or court order requires removal.
  • Publication causes a serious and continuing privacy or confidentiality violation.
  • Content creates a substantial and credible risk to individual safety.
  • A serious copyright or intellectual-property violation requires restriction of access.
  • Other compelling legal or ethical circumstances make continued public access inappropriate.
Preservation of the Scholarly Record Where legally permissible, the journal will retain the article's bibliographic metadata, DOI, and a public notice explaining the removal. Full-text removal does not ordinarily require deletion of the publication history or bibliographic record.
5. Expressions of Concern

An Expression of Concern is a public editorial notice indicating that serious questions about a published article remain unresolved.

An Expression of Concern may be issued when:

  • An investigation into potential research misconduct is ongoing.
  • Serious concerns are supported by preliminary evidence but remain inconclusive.
  • Important underlying research documentation cannot yet be verified.
  • An institutional investigation is delayed or has not produced a clear outcome.
  • Further independent assessment is required before a defensible decision can be made.

The notice must clearly identify the affected article, explain the unresolved concern in objective language, and be linked to the original publication.

Important Distinction: An Expression of Concern is not a retraction or a finding of misconduct. It should be reviewed when relevant new evidence becomes available and may be followed by a correction, retraction, or notice resolving the concern.
6. Correction Policy (Errata and Corrigenda)

Corrections are issued when a published article contains a material error or omission that should be amended but does not render the article as a whole unreliable.

Corrections may address:

  • Factual inaccuracies or incomplete descriptions.
  • Errors in statistical tables, figures, or data presentation.
  • Incorrect variable definitions or analytical descriptions.
  • Errors in author names, affiliations, or publication metadata.
  • Omitted funding, acknowledgment, or conflict-of-interest information.
  • Incorrect references, DOI information, or attribution details.
  • Other material omissions that can be corrected without invalidating the main findings.
Minor Technical Changes Spelling, formatting, or typographical errors that do not affect interpretation may be corrected administratively without a separate formal notice, provided the changes do not obscure material publication history.
Material Corrections Errors affecting interpretation, attribution, analytical presentation, or scholarly understanding require an identifiable correction and appropriate documentation.

The Editorial Team must verify the reported issue before determining whether a formal correction is necessary.

7. Correction Procedure and Version Control
  1. Error Identification: The issue is identified by an author, editor, reviewer, reader, or another relevant party.
  2. Verification: The handling editor examines the issue and may request supporting information.
  3. Editorial Assessment: The editor determines whether the error affects the article's findings, interpretation, metadata, or other material content.
  4. Decision: The Editor-in-Chief or authorized editor approves the appropriate corrective action.
  5. Notice and Amendment: A correction notice is published when necessary and linked to the original article.
  6. Metadata Update: Relevant online records and article metadata are updated, with a dated record of the change.
Online-First and Early View Articles Corrections may be integrated into an online-first article with a documented change history before issue assignment, where the versioning procedure permits.
Articles Published in an Issue Material changes generally require a separately identifiable correction notice that is permanently linked to the original article.

Substantive changes must not be introduced through silent replacement of an already published Version of Record.

8. Article Replacement and Publication Versioning

Where a formal replacement or revised publication version is justified, the journal must ensure that readers can identify the relationship between the original and updated content.

  • Identify the reason for replacement or republication.
  • Preserve appropriate information about the original publication.
  • Provide the date and nature of the amendment.
  • Clearly identify any new version of the article.
  • Maintain appropriate links between related versions.
  • Update persistent identifiers and publication metadata where necessary.

The journal does not silently substitute a materially revised Version of Record for an earlier published version without appropriate notice or documented version history.

9. Requirements for Public Editorial Notices

Formal Retraction, Withdrawal, Correction, Removal, and Expression of Concern notices must be clear, accurate, accessible, and appropriately linked to the affected scholarly content.

Each applicable notice should include:

  • A clear notice type in the title.
  • The original article title and author information.
  • The original journal citation and publication date.
  • The article DOI or other persistent identifier.
  • The reason for the editorial action.
  • The individual or editorial authority issuing the notice.
  • The notice publication date.
  • Appropriate links to the original article and any related editorial notices.
Notice Language: Editorial notices must be factual, objective, proportionate, and non-inflammatory. They should not imply that research misconduct has been established when the available evidence supports only an honest error or unresolved concern.
10. DOI, Indexing and Metadata Updates

The journal seeks to ensure that the status of corrected, retracted, or otherwise amended articles is communicated accurately to readers and scholarly discovery services.

Appropriate actions may include:

  • Marking the original article page with its editorial status.
  • Clearly marking a retracted article's PDF and HTML where applicable.
  • Maintaining links between the original article and the relevant notice.
  • Registering appropriate notice identifiers where supported.
  • Updating Crossref metadata and relationships where technically supported.
  • Communicating relevant changes to indexing, archiving, and discovery services where possible.
  • Preserving the published article's original DOI and bibliographic identity.
Metadata Integrity: A retraction or correction must not be concealed by deleting article metadata or silently redirecting readers to an unrelated publication. Persistent identifiers and version relationships should remain accurate and traceable.
11. Editorial Responsibilities and Procedural Fairness

All R-W-C decisions must be supported by appropriate editorial oversight, responsible evidence assessment, and fair treatment of affected parties.

  • Authors: Must promptly report significant errors and cooperate in legitimate clarification or correction procedures.
  • Handling Editor: Examines concerns, coordinates evidence review, and recommends appropriate editorial action.
  • Editor-in-Chief: Oversees or determines the final scholarly action within the journal's approved authority.
  • Publisher: Supports publication notices, metadata maintenance, archival continuity, and legally necessary actions.
  • Research Institutions: May investigate allegations of researcher misconduct and provide relevant findings.

Editors with material conflicts of interest should not determine the outcome of the affected case. An appropriate independent editor or authorized editorial representative should handle the matter instead.

12. Appeals, Confidentiality and Record-Keeping

Authors or other affected parties may raise reasoned concerns about the fairness or factual basis of an editorial decision through the journal's Complaint Handling Procedure.

Requests for reconsideration must identify the relevant decision and provide supporting evidence. An appeal does not automatically suspend a necessary correction or retraction.

The Editorial Office maintains appropriate records of:

  • Reported concerns and relevant supporting materials.
  • Author responses and editorial correspondence.
  • Independent expert assessments and institutional communications.
  • Editorial decisions and supporting reasons.
  • Published notices, version changes, and metadata updates.

Confidential information must be protected in accordance with applicable legal, privacy, and editorial obligations. Public notices should provide sufficient explanation without unnecessarily disclosing sensitive personal information.

13. Reporting Errors and Requesting Editorial Action

Authors, reviewers, readers, institutions, or other relevant parties may report suspected errors, unreliable findings, or ethical concerns to the Moneta Editorial Office.

Official Reporting Channel

Email: [email protected]

Subject: R-W-C Policy Inquiry - Manuscript ID / Article DOI

Requests should provide:

  • The manuscript title or published article citation.
  • Submission identification number or DOI, where available.
  • A clear description of the issue or requested amendment.
  • Supporting evidence or relevant documentation.
  • Contact information and the submitter's relationship to the article.
Submit R-W-C Inquiry
Commitment to Scholarly Record Integrity

Moneta: Journal of Economics and Finance is committed to protecting the accuracy, credibility, and long-term reliability of scholarly research. Corrections, retractions, Expressions of Concern, withdrawals, and exceptional removals are handled through transparent and proportionate procedures that preserve an accurate history of the publication record.

Retraction Unreliable Work
Withdrawal Pre-Publication
Correction Correctable Error
Concern Unresolved Issue
Editorial Guidance and Standards
MONETA: JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS AND FINANCE
PT Penerbit Ilmiah Indonesia • Indonesian Scientific Publication (IDSCIPUB)
Publication Ethics • Editorial Transparency • Scholarly Record Integrity