Peer Review Process

MONETA • EDITORIAL PROCESS
Peer-Review Process

Moneta: Journal of Economics and Finance

Moneta: Journal of Economics and Finance follows a rigorous and transparent editorial process to ensure the quality, originality, methodological soundness, and credibility of published scholarly articles.

The journal applies a double-blind (double-anonymous) peer-review system. Each manuscript passing editorial screening is evaluated by a minimum of two independent expert reviewers.

Double-Blind Review Model
Minimum 2 Independent Reviewers
3 Weeks Revision Period
Editor-in-Chief Final Decision
Peer-Review Workflow
Moneta Journal Peer-Review Process Flowchart
1. Submission and Initial Evaluation

All submitted manuscripts undergo initial evaluation by the Editorial Team to assess their relevance to Moneta's scope and compliance with manuscript submission requirements.

The Editor-in-Chief screens each submission. Eligible manuscripts receive an identification number and are assigned to a handling editor with relevant expertise. Manuscripts failing the initial screening may be rejected without external review.

2. Review Model

Moneta adopts a double-blind peer-review model to promote impartiality and scientific independence.

  • Authors' identities are concealed from reviewers.
  • Reviewers' identities are concealed from authors.
  • Manuscripts are evaluated based on scholarly quality rather than author identity or institutional affiliation.
3. Reviewer Selection

Each manuscript passing initial screening is assigned to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in its relevant research area.

  • Reviewers are selected based on subject expertise, academic experience, and scholarly competence.
  • The handling editor coordinates reviewer selection and evaluation.
  • Potential conflicts of interest should be considered when assigning reviewers.
  • An additional reviewer may be appointed when assessments differ substantially.
4. Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewers are expected to provide independent, objective, constructive, and evidence-based assessments of manuscripts submitted to Moneta.

  • Originality: Assess novelty and contribution to economics and finance.
  • Scientific Quality: Evaluate theoretical foundations, research methods, analysis, and evidence.
  • Relevance: Assess conformity with the journal's Focus and Scope.
  • Presentation: Evaluate clarity, structure, academic writing, and references.
  • Research Ethics: Identify possible ethical concerns, plagiarism, or inappropriate reporting.
Reviewer Responsibilities: Maintain confidentiality, disclose conflicts of interest, avoid personal criticism, provide reasoned recommendations, and report suspected misconduct confidentially to the editor.
5. Confidentiality

Moneta maintains strict confidentiality throughout the review process. Reviewers and editors must treat submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports, and unpublished findings as confidential information. Such materials must not be disclosed, distributed, or used for unauthorized purposes.

6. Decision Process

The handling editor evaluates the reviewers' recommendations and forwards the assessment for editorial consideration.

Accept
Minor Revision
Major Revision
Reject

The Editor-in-Chief makes the final publication decision in consultation with the handling editor and Editorial Board. Reviewer recommendations inform the decision but do not independently determine acceptance or rejection. A resubmission may also be requested when substantial changes are required.

7. Revision Process
Revision Deadline: Three Weeks

Authors are given three weeks to address reviewer comments and resubmit revised manuscripts.

  • Revise the manuscript according to reviewer and editorial recommendations.
  • Submit a point-by-point response to every reviewer comment.
  • Highlight or clearly identify changes in the revised manuscript.

The handling editor reassesses the revision and may request further changes or additional reviewer evaluation when necessary.

8. Appeals

Authors who believe an editorial decision was affected by a significant factual error, procedural irregularity, or misunderstanding may submit a formal appeal to the Moneta Editorial Office.

An appeal should include:

  • The manuscript title and identification number.
  • The editorial decision being appealed.
  • A clear explanation of the grounds for reconsideration.
  • Relevant evidence or supporting documentation.

The Editor-in-Chief assesses the appeal and may seek independent editorial or expert advice when appropriate. Editors with relevant conflicts of interest should not participate in the reassessment.

Appeal Principle: An appeal does not guarantee reversal of an editorial decision. Reconsideration must be based on substantive evidence and procedural fairness.
9. Review Duration

Moneta strives to ensure timely manuscript evaluation without compromising review quality. Reviewers are assigned a specified period for assessment. The duration may vary depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, and the need for additional review. Authors will be informed of relevant estimated timelines during the editorial process.

10. Review Process Improvement

Moneta continuously seeks to improve peer-review quality, efficiency, fairness, and editorial transparency. Constructive feedback from authors and reviewers is welcomed and may be used to strengthen editorial procedures and scholarly evaluation standards.

11. Editorial Contact

For inquiries concerning manuscript evaluation, reviewer reports, revisions, editorial decisions, or appeals, please contact the Moneta Editorial Team.

[email protected]
Editorial Commitment

Moneta: Journal of Economics and Finance is committed to rigorous, independent, confidential, constructive, and fair peer review. Editorial decisions are guided by scientific merit, originality, relevance, and compliance with ethical publication standards.

MONETA: JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS AND FINANCE
Indonesian Scientific Publication (IDSCIPUB)